Sunday, February 3, 2008

Nonviolence Doesn't Always Work - But Violins Never Do

The thing I find most objectionable about the majority of classical music is the instrumental timbres. Most notably the strings. Most notably the violins. I don’t mind trios or quartets, but in the symphony orchestra setting (where the string musicians outnumber the amount of players on a professional football squad) the cacophony becomes unbearable. Stringed instruments are capable of two sounds: quick screeching notes like nails on a chalkboard, or long dizzying vibratos like spinning in a circle to the point of nausea. Violins are the most offensive of the string family due to their high, piercing register.

On the subject of timbre, Brandenburg Concerto No. 6 rates fairly well in my book. The whole work is in a lower register than most, without as much squeaking and shuddering as usual.
Allmusic.com tells me that this piece lacks the presence of violins. The instrumentation consists of two violas, two violas da gamba, a cello, a violone, and a harpsichord: not as cluttered as an orchestra, but a little more busy than a quartet. The choice of instrumentation is unusual as the violins are usually the stars of the show, responsible for the main melody. Brandenburg 6 is more diplomatic, with a polyphonic division of melody between the string players.

The rhythm in movements 1 and 3 is incessant and pounding, like a bad hangover. Though there are many notes being played, they don’t seem to be serving a purpose. Much of the piece sounds like the string players are practicing their arpeggios. The second movement is a welcome intermission from this monotonous, pulsating beat.

I’ve listened Brandenburg 6 many times during the past week and yet, save for the first few seconds of the first movement, it has failed to stick in my long term memory. That is so say, I don’t hear a hook. There are some interesting harmonic movements in the work, but the melody, instead of striking out on its own, seems only to serve by reinforcing chord tones.

If I was Brandenburg, I wouldn’t have given Bach a job either.

No comments: